Tungsten Carbide Grit: Form and Size Matter
Tungsten carbide grit is not one material. Crushed, fused, and spherical forms behave differently in hardfacing; specify form, size method, and lot evidence.
Target Audience and Why This Problem Exists
This guide is for buyers and process engineers who see "tungsten carbide grit" on an RFQ or hardfacing datasheet. It can mean feedstock, a welding consumable, or the input to a sintered part, so price alone cannot identify it.
Start with the Product Form
Ask the supplier to name the production route, morphology, and delivery state before discussing price. The same trade term may describe a crushed particle, a fused angular particle, a spherical powder, or a blend with binder or matrix metal.
| Form named in an inquiry | Verify first | Why the distinction matters |
|---|---|---|
| Crushed grit | Source, WC-Co ratio, contamination, shape | Fragments differ from cast particles |
| Fused or cast grit | Phase, angularity, size cut | Hard phase and matrix response depend on manufacture |
| Spherical powder | Sphericity, satellites, distribution, flow | Flow and matrix response differ |
| WC blend | Chemistry, oxygen, binder mixing, segregation | Small changes affect sintering or deposition |
Lee and Kim compared spherical, fused angular, and mixed WC powders in plasma transferred arc hardfacing. Spherical WC and a higher WC quantity improved wear resistance in their dry-sand-wheel test, but interfacial phases and cooling also affected the result; treat this as process-specific evidence (DOI:10.3390/met11122035).
Read the Particle-Size Claim as a Method
Ask for the measurement method, sample preparation, and full distribution. ASTM B214 covers sieve analysis of metal powders; ASTM B822 covers distribution by light scattering (ASTM B214 and ASTM B822). A mesh label is one cut. Report D10, D50, and D90 in µm, retain the raw curve, and state dry-sieved or liquid-dispersed sampling.
Do not copy a size value from a procedure into a powder order unless the sampling and measurement basis match. For welding, include cut, morphology, flow, moisture, and deposition procedure. For a sintered part, connect powder to pressing, sintering, shrinkage, and finished geometry.
Match Chemistry to Delivery State
Specify the chemical basis even when the supplier uses a familiar name. WC-Co grit can differ in cobalt, free carbon, oxygen, iron, and phase constitution. Fused carbide may contain phases other than WC, and a blend can segregate. Require the measured value, sampling method, detection limit, and acceptance rule.
For a sintered part, Carbidea's production class is YG6X-grade fine-grain WC-Co at approximately 6% Co, with reference density 14.9-15.0 g/cm3. As-sintered stock may be 0.1-0.25 mm; check density by ASTM B311 and porosity by ASTM B276. These tests describe the part, not the grit.
Qualify the Lot and the Process
Grit becomes useful only after process qualification. For hardfacing, define substrate, preheat, deposition method, heat input, dilution, layer thickness, cooling, finishing allowance, and inspection. For a finished part, define pressing, sintering, shrinkage allowance, grinding datum, and acceptance.
Ask for a lot record that connects material identity to test results. A catalog grade without a lot number, sample basis, or method is not enough. If material is reclaimed or crushed from used parts, require source, cleaning, contamination check, and phase analysis.
For a part rather than loose consumable, the acceptance question changes. Carbidea quotes made-to-print sintered and ground components, not loose grit. Ground features can be quoted within 0.005-0.01 mm where the drawing confirms them; this tolerance belongs to the part, not to a grit sieve cut.
A Practical RFQ Sequence
- Name the form: grit, powder, blend, blank, or part.
- State the material route and morphology, including WC and binder phases.
- Specify the size method and D10, D50, and D90 values.
- Define deposition or sintering, mating surface, and acceptance.
- Require lot traceability, a sample, and safety information.
- Compare quantity, state, packaging, test scope, and delivery.
Related Products & Topics
- Compare hardfacing with solid carbide.
- Review the grade datasheet checklist.
- Read preform allowances or browse profile blanks.
FAQ
Q: Is grit the same as tungsten carbide powder?
A: No. Grit usually implies a controlled cut; powder may include more fines. Ask for morphology, route, and full distribution.
Q: Which morphology should I choose?
A: No universal answer. Lee and Kim found an advantage for spherical WC in one PTAW test, but WC quantity, interfacial phases, peak temperature, and cooling also mattered.
Q: Can I specify grit by mesh size alone?
A: No. Mesh does not define method, fines tail, oversize, morphology, chemistry, or lot. Use a sieve or light-scattering method and retain the distribution.
Q: Does Carbidea sell loose grit?
A: Carbidea's listed production scope is made-to-print sintered and ground parts, not loose grit. Send the drawing, duty, grade, quantity, and acceptance requirements.